Derby County

Verified Timeline

Lore & Background

The first meeting of Derby County and Nottingham Forest came in the 1892–93 First Division. The first competitive fixture was held on 1 October 1892 at the Racecourse Ground, which Nottingham Forest won 3–2. The return fixture in January 1893 also ended in victory for Nottingham Forest, 1–0. It was not until the 1894–95 season that Derby secured a first win, coming out on top 4–2 in September 1894. Although the clubs are rivals because of their geographical proximity, the rivalry intensified after January 1975 when Brian Clough was appointed Forest manager, much to the dismay of the Derby support. Duncan Hamilton, writing in The Times, remarked that the rivalry is as much about which club owns Clough's heart as about the proximity of the clubs geographically. Since 2007, the winning team has been awarded the Brian Clough Trophy, in memory of Brian Clough, who managed both clubs. The inaugural match was held at Derby's Pride Park Stadium on 31 July 2007, which the host team won 2–0. As of the 2021–22 season, Forest were the holders, having retained the trophy after a 2–1 win at Nottingham's City Ground on 22 January 2022. Since the inauguration of the Brian Clough Trophy, fans from both sides have nicknamed the fixture El Cloughico, in reference to the El Clásico rivalry between Spanish football teams FC Barcelona and Real Madrid CF.

In Their Own Story

The rain lashes against the floodlights at the City Ground as the clock ticks past ninety minutes. The air is thick with steam and the roar of a thousand Forest fans chanting in unison. On the pitch, the red shirts of Nottingham Forest press forward against the blue and white stripes of Derby County. Every tackle feels heavier, every pass more urgent; this isn't just three points on the line, it's the pride of the county hanging in the balance.

Reader's Guide

The origins of the East Midlands Derby stretch back to the late 19th century when both clubs were establishing themselves as regional powers. Early meetings were often friendly but competitive, setting a tone that would evolve into fierce hostility over decades. Key historical clashes include numerous battles in the top flight during Forest's golden eras under Brian Clough and later in the mid-2000s when both teams were fighting for Premier League survival. These matches often decided who would remain in the division, adding immense pressure to every encounter. Culturally, the rivalry is significant because it represents a clash of identities between two cities that are close geographically but distinct in character. For fans, beating Derby County is a badge of honor that resonates through generations of supporters. Over time, while the financial and competitive landscapes have shifted, the emotional core remains unchanged. The fixture continues to be one of the most anticipated events on the calendar for both sets of fans.

Did You Know?

• According to an unofficial survey, 9 out of 10 fans from Derby and Forest name the other as their 'fiercest rival', making this the sixth fiercest rivalry in English football.
• The Brian Clough Trophy was first awarded on 31 July 2007 at Derby's Pride Park Stadium, where the hosts won 2–0.
• Fans have nicknamed the fixture 'El Cloughico', in reference to the El Clásico rivalry between FC Barcelona and Real Madrid CF.
• Referee Stuart Attwell disallowed two late Derby goals in a 2008 match, leading to him being removed from the following week's fixture list.
• The 2011–12 season saw Derby claim their first league double over Forest since 1972.

Origins and Historical Context

The rivalry between Derby County and Nottingham Forest traces its roots back over a century, originating in the early days of organized English football. Their first competitive encounter occurred on October 1, 1892, at the Racecourse Ground during the inaugural season following the merger of the Football League and the rival Football Alliance. At that time, Derby were established founder members, while Forest had recently secured the Alliance title before being invited into the expanded First Division. Nottingham Forest initially dominated these early meetings, winning both fixtures in the 1892–93 campaign with scores of 3–2 and 1–0 respectively. It was not until September 1894 that Derby finally broke this streak, securing a decisive 4–2 victory. While geographical proximity naturally fostered competition, the fixture evolved into one of England's most significant rivalries due to shared history and intense local pride. The clubs spent thirteen consecutive seasons competing side-by-side in the EFL Championship before their paths diverged significantly at the end of the 2021–22 season, with Forest ascending to the Premier League while Derby suffered relegation to League One.

The Brian Clough Factor and Trophy

Although the clubs have competed for over a hundred years, the intensity of the rivalry reached new heights in the late 1970s following the appointment of Brian Clough as Nottingham Forest manager. This move caused significant dismay among Derby supporters, leading to a sentiment that the fixture was as much about which club truly owned Clough's heart as it was about geography. To honor his legacy after managing both teams successfully, the 'Brian Clough Trophy' was inaugurated in 2007, awarded annually to the winner of their encounter. The inaugural match took place at Derby's Pride Park Stadium on July 31, 2007, where the hosts triumphed 2–0. Since then, fans have affectionately dubbed the fixture 'El Cloughico,' drawing a parallel to the famous Spanish rivalry between Barcelona and Real Madrid. Nottingham Forest currently hold the trophy after retaining it with a 2–1 victory at their City Ground home in January 2022, cementing this modern tradition as a central pillar of the contest's identity.

Controversy, Violence, and Discipline

The East Midlands Derby is notoriously volatile, frequently marred by hooliganism, on-pitch altercations, and disciplinary issues. A particularly infamous incident occurred in November 2008 when referee Stuart Attwell disallowed two late goals for Derby, issued eight bookings, and sent off Forest's Lewis McGugan. The controversy was so severe that Attwell was removed from the fixture list shortly after, with manager Paul Jewell accusing him of losing control and 'robbing' his team. Tensions escalated further in 2009 following managerial appointments and player transfers between the clubs, leading to fractious FA Cup ties and post-match scuffles. One notable altercation involved Nathan Tyson celebrating with a Forest corner flag, resulting in fines for both clubs and a charge of improper conduct against Tyson. Subsequent meetings saw repeated red cards and physical clashes, including a brawl involving Chris Gunter and Jay McEveley in 2010. The fixture has seen players sent off in four consecutive matches starting in January 2011, highlighting the persistent animosity that often overshadows the sport itself.

Modern Competitive Dynamics

In recent decades, the competitive balance of the East Midlands Derby has fluctuated dramatically, producing memorable results and shifting momentum. The 2011–12 season marked a significant turnaround for Derby, who achieved their first league double over Forest since 1972 en route to winning the Championship title. This included a dramatic comeback at the City Ground where they recovered from being a man down to win 2–1. The rivalry saw record-breaking performances as well; in March 2014, Derby secured a stunning 5–0 victory at Pride Park, equalling the largest margin of defeat in the fixture's history. While both teams have traded home wins and draws over the years, such as the 2–2 draw in March 2017, the fixture remains fiercely contested. The divergence in league status following the 2021–22 season added a new layer to the narrative, with Forest moving up to the Premier League while Derby dropped to League One, potentially altering the frequency and nature of their future encounters.

Gallery